KernelTrap: Journaling Filesystem Shootout

"Mike Benoit recently posted a link to results from his new and improved file system shootout, using better hardware and running more tests. Using two benchmarks that are designed to measure hard drive and file system performance, Bonnie++ and IOZone, he's compared a number journaling filesystems found in the 2.6 kernel. Included in the lineup are EXT2 (not journaling, but an effective baseline [story]), JFS, XFS, ReiserFS, Reiser4, and EXT3 each compared head to head on both SCSI and IDE drives.

"In Mike's summary he labels JFS and XFS as 'best bang for your buck' explaining, 'While not the fastest file systems, both of them consistently perform close to EXT2, while using minimal CPU. XFS seems to be faster over a wider range of benchmarks, however it does use slightly more CPU than JFS. While JFS really starts to slow down with lots of files.' As for pure speed, Mike points to Reiser4 which really shined in the Bonnie++ benchmarks, though not quite so much in the IOZone benchmarks. He suggests, 'ReiserFS v4 will [definitely] be worth while keeping an eye on, especially considering some of the exciting new features it offers...'"

Complete Story

Related Stories:

• Linux Orbit Professional: Journalling Filesystems: An Intro to Reiserfs(Jan 30, 2003)
• Redhatbox.org: Wow! 'ext3' really Works!(Oct 25, 2001)
• Linux Gazette: Journaling Filesystems for Linux(Jul 02, 2001)