Speaking of Mouse Trap Economics, What About that Yarn that Patents Stimulate Invention

"Based on my 40 years of experience in the computer system development, much of it before software patents were introduced, I believe that the alleged connection between such patents and the stimulation of innovation is tenuous at best and probably negative. Let me confess that even though I oppose the continuation of software patents, as a defensive measure I've applied for some that have been granted.

"When I entered the field as a programmer in 1954 there were only about a hundred of us in the whole world, and each of us was turning out thousands of inventions each year, or maybe it was hundreds depending on your standards, but a lot. Software was given the same kinds of protection as other documentation, namely copyright and trade secret.

"It was certainly a good thing that there were no software patents because my colleagues and I could have papered over the field and retired for 17 years or so to collect royalties. Since patents didn't exist, we kept working and had quite a good time doing it, sharing ideas and standing on each other's shoulders to see how high we could reach."

Complete Story

Related Stories:

• Why Oracle was right to sue Google(Aug 23, 2010)
• Oracle vs Google: Triple Damage!(Aug 20, 2010)
• Lawsuit Raises Questions about Open Invention Network, Linux Foundation(Aug 19, 2010)
• Patents, Patents, Everywhere...(May 04, 2010)
• First, we kill all the patent lawyers(May 04, 2010)
• Jobs on Flash: Hypocrisy So Thick You Could Cut it with a Knife(Apr 30, 2010)
• Darkness Visible: Making Patent Absurdity Patent(Apr 16, 2010)