dcsimg
Linux Today: Linux News On Internet Time.




More on LinuxToday


Byte.com: GNashing KDE And Other Non-Trivial Pursuits - Closed vs. Open Source Stuff

Sep 18, 2000, 22:14 (1 Talkback[s])
(Other stories by Tom Henderson)

WEBINAR:
On-Demand

Re-Imagining Linux Platforms to Meet the Needs of Cloud Service Providers


"The conversation ambled toward one of his first loves, KDE. "It's not a boxers vs. briefs argument. Although the copyright/copyleft arguments made against KDE aren't very fair, what I get with Gnome is simplicity. If I actually get to move code simply over onto other platforms, so much the better. Gnome isn't rocket science," he said, "and it's also not Windows or the Mac UI, either. But the ethnic purity arguments are . KDE is cool, Gnome is cool, but Gnome is an attitude where KDE is a more evolved front-end...."

"Looking at the CVS trees that exist for many important Linux apps (let alone the kernel), I wonder about the efficacy of business plans that revolve around the constant-upgrade business, and how open source methodologies seem to wash the negative effects. Let me think aloud. The commercial successes in software development may have started differently, but most have wound up with a similar plan. The plan is designed to seduce you, the decision makers into buying into a specific product or product grouping. Eventually, you wear the logo on your sleeve. A salesperson would say that they have the hook in your mouth, as in fishing. The job at that point is to pull hard. That's because the initial license purchase is only a fraction of the life cycle of revenue that's in the plan...."

"There seems to be a point where code development never stops, unless the code has become a reasonable and stable platform for something else, or until it can't be supported as attention has shifted to something else. It seems that no code is finished. Only interest seems to shift. There is, in Linux, the great temptation to constantly update. Some of it's good as an evolving platform. Some of it's bad because it's not driven by the need for solidification."

Complete Story

Related Stories: