Linux Today at COMDEX: KDE League Formalized with Press Conference, Granroth Addresses Critics
Nov 16, 2000, 00:54 (3 Talkback[s])
(Other stories by Michael Hall)
Re-Imagining Linux Platforms to Meet the Needs of Cloud Service Providers
By Michael Hall at
COMDEX in Las Vegas
After spending a few days as a poorly guarded secret, the KDE
League held a press conference at COMDEX to formally announce the
group's launch and allow KDE developer Kurt Granroth an opportunity
to discuss his past statements about the GNOME Foundation in light
of the new organization's formation.
Chris Schlaeger, president of KDE League spent a few minutes
introducing the KDE project to attendees, noting that KDE is in
use, according to an Evans Data study earlier this year, on 70% of
all Linux machines. According to Schlaeger, the purpose of the
League is to "establish KDE as a standard" both on desktop systems
and in mobile devices.
Schlaeger carefully emphasized that the League will have no
influence on the KDE development process, and that it isn't a
steering commitee or advisory board. Rather, he said "you could
call it a marketing organization," designed to promote KDE and act
as a mediating body between organizations with an interest in the
"Technical excellence alone does not guarantee widespread use,"
said Schlaeger, who called the formation of the GNOME Foundation a
"wakeup call" for the need to address promotion of KDE.
KDE Developer and frequent commentator Kurt Granroth provided a
few words of explanation for how the KDE League isn't
representative of a reversal of his comments regarding the GNOME
Foundation immediately after that organization was founded.
Granroth has been accused of embracing an organization he said
would never have a place in the KDE community. According to
Granroth, once the corporate sponsorship and non-profit status the
two organizations are discarded, the differences between the two
"KDE," said Granroth, echoing Schlaeger's comments, "will never
have any corporate direction in our development."
As a result of these differences, said Granroth, he will never
retract previous commentary he wrote on community sites or
statements he made to others regarding the chances of a GNOME
Foundation-like organization forming around KDE.
Granroth also took an uncompetitive tone as he spoke about the
"GNOME is not the enemy," he said, noting that with Linux
currently occupying around 5% of the desktop market, infighting
between the two projects will hinder further acceptance of Linux in
that area. Granroth also pointed out that many of the members of
the new league are also members of the GNOME Foundation, and
"they're not going to shoot themselves in the foot."
According to Granroth, the idea for the KDE League wasn't
particularly new, having been in the planning stages for about a
year, though the announcement of the GNOME Foundation had a "little
bit" of an influence on the decision to finally launch the group
after several stalls. In the wake of the announcement of the GNOME
Foundation, said Granroth, members of the KDE Project received a
"huge barrage of e-mails" from members of their user community and
elsewhere, encouraging them to launch the organization.
Questions were raised during the press conference regarding the
notable absence of Red Hat from the list of distributions forming
the charter membership of the group, to which League chairman
Andreas Pour said the company is still considering membership. Pour
wouldn't comment on the reason Red Hat may have for delaying
membership, except to say that he doesn't "have any knowledge" of
their ultimate intentions. Pour also addressed the absence of VA
Linux from the group, pointing out that though the company isn't a
member of the organization, they provide support to the KDE project
via their SourceForge site, where KDE is hosted.
Pour said membership to the league isn't closed, and that other
companies will be permitted to join as they wish.
IBM's representative, Sheila Harnett of the IBM Linux Technology
Center, announced that IBM will be working with TrollTech and
Mandrake to bring components of ViaVoice to the KDE environment.
Part of IBM's long-term strategy with Linux and KDE includes use of
the OS and environment on mobile devices. TrollTech is on hand at
COMDEX demonstrating a "proof of concept" of their Qt/Embedded
palmtop environment, which will no doubt play a part in the use of
KDE in mobile environments.
Representatives from the other corporate members were also on
hand, making brief statements in support of both the League and the
KDE project. The KDE League is currently comprised of Borland,
Caldera, Corel, Fujitsu-Siemens, Hewlett Packard, IBM, KDE.com,
Klaralvdalens Datakonsult, theKompany.com, Mandrakesoft, SuSE,
TrollTech, and TurboLinux.
- LinuxNews.com: IBM, KDE Relationship Deepens; IBM to Voice-Enable KDE(Nov 15, 2000)
- LinuxPR: Borland Joins Gnome Foundation Advisory Board(Nov 15, 2000)
- eWeek: Linux backers to announce KDE League(Nov 15, 2000)
- LinuxPR: Open Source Developers And Industry Leaders Unify To Create The KDE League(Nov 15, 2000)
- LinuxPlanet: .comment: Weaseling a Good Idea(Nov 15, 2000)
- ZDNet: KDE backers to form a league of their own; KDE League comparable to GNOME Foundation(Nov 13, 2000)
- ZDNet: Open source: KDE hits back at GNOME(Sep 08, 2000)
- KDE: Official Response to GNOME Foundation(Sep 01, 2000)
- LinuxPlanet: .comment: Disco Night at the Old Folks' Home(Aug 30, 2000)
- LinuxPower: GNOME triumphant, now lets rally to give users a real choice(Aug 29, 2000)
- LinuxPlanet: Peace and Bread in Time of War: GNOME Defended(Aug 28, 2000)
- Slashdot: KDE Developer on the GNOME Foundation(Aug 19, 2000)
- LWN: A talk with KDE developer Kurt Granroth(Aug 17, 2000)
- The Register: KDE responds: we're not scared(Aug 15, 2000)