Linux Today: Linux News On Internet Time.

IT-Director: Desktop Wars; KDE vs. GNOME ...vs. Windows vs. OS/2 vs. Mac OS

Jan 12, 2001, 16:36 (17 Talkback[s])
(Other stories by Father William)

"Good points are not the only road that KDE and GNOME share. Bugs and a general "flaky" reliability were all too common in the earlier releases. Both have been lacking features and documentation, despite the ease of getting the most common tasks completed comfortably. Neither has reached the standard of OS2Warp or MACOS, but they are drawing closer by the day."

"However, there is fighting amongst the troops from both camps. KDE released a letter that disparages GNOME as little more than a warmed up Motif or Common Desktop environment (CDE). It "must be inferior" as the KDE team released their first version about a year before the GNOME's. Could it be jealousy on their part, as GNOME seems to have the more sophisticated and configurable file manager (sawfish)? GNOME was the "chosen one" that received the backing from numerous hardware suppliers and software vendors, including the likes of IBM and Hewlett Packard. This gave birth to the GNOME foundation. In retaliation, KDE aimed directly for the file manager, releasing Konquerer a more able version than GNOME, incorporating a web browser that supports not only html, but cookies too. KDE has the advantage of the plug-in architecture."

"If any sane person is not confused by the choice, then it is a "Mad Mad Mad world", but we can blame incoherence in the Open Source movement for that..."

Complete Story

Related Stories: