SJ Mercury: Looking for wisdom and hints of outcome in Microsoft's antitrust appeal
Feb 28, 2001, 16:42 (18 Talkback[s])
Desktop-as-a-Service Designed for Any Cloud ? Nutanix Frame
"Legal scholars always caution against reading too much into
appellate judges' questions. But what were we to make of it when
Harry Edwards, chief judge of the appeals court, told the
government attorney to assume that software markets tend to create
monopolies. If so, he asked, was this antitrust case all about
protecting a wannabe monopoly so it can replace the current one?
After all, he said, citing evidence from both sides in the case,
technology markets gravitate toward standards."
"Was Douglas Ginsburg telegraphing anything when he referred to
Microsoft's "carpet-bombing" of Netscape during the browser war?
Did A. Raymond Randolph, who was in the majority of a three-judge
panel that backed Microsoft in an earlier, related case, just want
to rule outright for Microsoft and go home?"
"The judges didn't let Microsoft's lawyer, Richard Urowsky, off
the hook with softballs. They did sound more inclined to accept his
answers, which at times bordered on the absurd, as when he
maintained the knee-slapping fiction that Microsoft doesn't enjoy a
monopoly. Urowsky... made more than one pair of eyes go wide
when he claimed that PC makers aren't the software company's real
customers, that the people who buy the computers are the real
customers. ... Actually, Microsoft specifically denies that you and
I are its customers in other courtrooms. As it defends itself
against antitrust suits filed by plaintiff's attorneys who want to
carve a hunk of flesh from the biggest shark in the sea, the
company is claiming that only the PC makers have the standing to
sue, because they're the real customers."
- Salon: The greatest antitrust show on Earth. Again!(Feb 26, 2001)
- LinuxToday.com.au: Dastardly Deeds or Business as Usual? MS Influence on Corel(Feb 21, 2001)
- InfoWorld/Reuters: Bush antitrust pick seen against Microsoft breakup(Feb 17, 2001)
- CNET News.com: Microsoft investigated for Corel investment(Feb 14, 2001)
- InfoWorld: Report: Bush chooses MS-friendly antitrust chief(Feb 14, 2001)
- ZDNet: Open-source antitrust penalty for Microsoft?(Jan 26, 2001)
- Bloomberg News: Microsoft wins dismissal of 38 private antitrust suits(Jan 13, 2001)
- Reuters/Yahoo: Microsoft rivals hire Starr of Whitewater fame(Jan 13, 2001)
- ZDNet/Reuters: States still want Microsoft case, even if Bush backs away(Jan 08, 2001)
- SF Gate/AP: Supreme Court refuses to hear Microsoft antitrust case(Sep 26, 2000)
- The Register: MS tells EU it's always pushed standards, interoperability(Aug 04, 2000)
- CNET News.com/AP: EU opens antitrust case against Microsoft(Aug 03, 2000)