"Not surprisingly, it's been the open source authors who've
primarily been interested in doing books under a copyleft license.
Their goal is often that they want the work to become a living part
of the community itself -- to be redistributed widely, commented on
by many, added to by some, taken in wildly different directions by
others, and so on, with the idea that it will ultimately lead to a
much better book and benefit everyone. It's a compelling vision and
one that I happen to like and admire tremendously."
"However, a book is not quite the same as a piece of
software. All kinds of interesting issues are raised, for both the
publisher and the author, when you try to publish a book under
copyleft. For the publisher, who has to invest $40-50K to
publish the book, the concerns are perhaps the greatest. For one
thing, under the copyleft license, there's the potential for a
competing publisher to simply republish the book. That's a
nightmare for almost any publisher to contemplate, and what's worse
is that because the competing publisher doesn't have to pay an
author royalties, and doesn't pay for editorial, they'd always be
able to undercut the original publisher on price because their
margins are so much better...."
"From the author's standpoint, it can get interesting as well.
Linux, remember, is given away for free. Tough for a derivative
product to harm its sales, because there aren't any sales in the
first place. Not so with a book. Also, resellers of Linux don't
make their money selling the product, they make it through
servicing the product. Also not so with a book, because there's
very little service necessary (unless you count an official Web
site that you direct readers to where you'd assimilate new
information and such, but it's still not quite the same)."
Some of the products that appear on this site are from companies from which QuinStreet receives compensation. This compensation may impact how and where products appear on this site including, for example, the order in which they appear. QuinStreet does not include all companies or all types of products available in the marketplace.