Linux Today: Linux News On Internet Time.

KDE Development Home: Unofficial Response to "Stallman on Qt, the GPL, KDE, and GNOME"

Sep 06, 2000, 13:31 (65 Talkback[s])

"Many of us woke up this morning and read Richard Stallman's editorial on Linux Today with a growing sense of incredulity. At first, some of us thought it was a joke -- it didn't make any logical sense, after all. But after it sunk in that Stallman was doing yet another snowjob on KDE, a lot of our incredulity turned to anger. If you want the official KDE position on his editorial, go here. But if you want to know how a few KDE developers feel, read on."

"Stallman has been a longtime detractor of the KDE Project. So much so, that his Free Software Foundation helped start a project whose only purpose was to be an "anti-KDE" -- GNOME. The GNOME developers themselves have gotten past all that and have created something that stands on its own merits. Stallman, though, seems to still be stuck in the past with his "KDE is bad, use GNOME to punish them" mantra."

"Basically, Stallman saw that with Qt under the GPL, all of his licensing problems went away. Ergo, there was nothing for him to fall back on anymore. So he comes up with this notion that we have to beg forgiveness of our copyright holders or we will be in violation of the GPL forever."

"Don't get us wrong; we could understand and accept that Stallman would still push GNOME over KDE -- it is under the GNU umbrella after all. That's fine. What isn't fine is inventing special rules after the fact just to bash KDE. This is hardly fair play."

Complete Story

Related Stories: