Linux Today: Linux News On Internet Time.

Fair Use, Turnitin, And... Why Google Never Should Have Caved On Book Scanning

Apr 23, 2009, 18:03 (0 Talkback[s])

"Unfortunately, as we all know, Google caved in that lawsuit and settled -- though, now we're watching as many are challenging whether the settlement terms are legal or reasonable. I still think Google should have stuck with the pure fair use defense, showing that its use was transformative and different - similar to just indexing websites for linking purposes. Not only is it unfortunate that Google gave this up, because it's one less strong precedent over fair use, but it's now opened up the ridiculous claims by a bunch of other industries (newspapers, recording) demanding that Google "settle" with them as well, and hand over cash."

Complete Story

Related Stories: