Arguments For Patents for Business Methods and Software-Implemented Inventions - And Some Against

Sep 29, 2009, 22:04 (0 Talkback[s])

"Steven J. Henry and Eric L. Amundsen, to be specific, were nice enough and brave enough to step up to the plate and explain why, in their view, based on their experience as IP attorneys, the sky will not fall no matter how Bilski is decided.

"I know, and they know -- because I made it clear -- that most of us here are opposed to software patents and disagree with their position. But they came anyway, and I appreciate it. Thank you both. Please treat them as my guests at this party, with respectful attention, and then explain to them in return, please, all the reasons you do or do not agree. References are ideal for expanding and deepening the conversation.

"It's particularly pertinent now to be having this discussion because the Supreme Court is going to be deciding the appeal of Bilski, and I thought it would be useful to consider a bit of the history of those kinds of patents and the cases that led to them being thought of as patentable subject matter. Groklaw can't file an amicus, but at least we can contribute to thinking about the issues. Think of it as tossing a note in a bottle into the ocean. You just never know who you might reach. When I go down the Patently O list of Bilski briefs now being filed with the Supreme Court, I don't see the pro-software/methods patents proponents even addressing the needs and concerns of the FOSS community."

Complete Story

Related Stories:

• Professor Hollaar's Amicus Brief in Bilski(Sep 23, 2009)
• The Role of Free Software in Education(Sep 22, 2009)
• First Sale - Davidson v. Internet Gateway(Sep 15, 2009)
• What Microsoft Doesn't Get - And What I Hope You Do(Sep 15, 2009)
• Microsoft and A Patent Checkmate of My Dreams - Updated(Sep 15, 2009)
• The i4i-Microsoft Appeal - HP and Dell Ask to File Amicus Briefs in Support of Microsoft(Aug 27, 2009)
• The Pelican Briefs - You're the fraudster! No, *you* are!(Aug 21, 2009)
• ASUS EeePC 1101HA: Why are two monopolies allowed to dictate what a netbook is allowed to be like?(Aug 15, 2009)
• Any Questions About the SCO Bankruptcy Hearing? I Have a Transcript(Aug 08, 2009)