Google et al Argue with Paul Allen's Interval Licensing: One Big Case or 11? Or None?
Nov 22, 2010, 07:03 (2 Talkback[s])
(Other stories by Pamela Jones)
Desktop-as-a-Service Designed for Any Cloud ? Nutanix Frame
"Do you remember when Google, Apple, Facebook, OfficeMax, Yahoo!
and Netflix/OfficeDepot/Staples/eBay all filed motions to dismiss
or sever Paul Allen's Interval Licensing's patent infringement
complaint? They filed to dismiss for misjoinder and Google filed a
motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim. Google and the
others want the cases separated into eleven instead of one
humungous case, if the court doesn't toss the complaint out.
"Allen has answered with his opposition to both ideas. And the
accused Gang of Eleven read the filings and their response could be
described simply like this: What do we all have in common? How can
it possibly work for any of us to have to go forward as a group?
And Google writes, "Interval has not identified any products of any
of the defendants that are allegedly infringing." All it has said
"without explanation" is that all the defendants infringe one of
its patents with "similar" functionality, but there are no facts to
support the claim. What functionality? What is the claim?
"All of them say the same thing: that Interval Licensing's
complaint is too vague, and thus they can't prepare. Google tells
"Interval's Complaint provides no notice as to what Google (or
any of the other named disparate Defendants) does that purportedly
infringes the patents-in-suit."
- Oracle declines to press its motion to dismiss, so motion is dismissed(Nov 19, 2010)
- Google Files Sizzling Answer to Oracle's Amended Complaint and its Opposition to Motion to Dismiss(Nov 12, 2010)
- EFF Pioneer Awards 2010 - Our thank you video(Nov 10, 2010)
- The IP Innovation v. Red Hat and Novell Trial Transcripts(Nov 04, 2010)
- Paul Allen v. the World lurches forward - Judge says no delay on initial disclosures(Nov 03, 2010)
- Oracle Gets Specific -- Files Amended Complaint - Update: And More, More, More(Oct 30, 2010)
- Day 11 in the SCO v. Novell Trial, Monday, March 22, 2010, Tibbitts, LaSala - as text(Oct 27, 2010)
- 4 EFF Pioneer Awards Winners for 2010 Announced - I am one of them(Oct 21, 2010)