VNU Net: Is HP basing its Unix future on Linux?
Aug 25, 2000, 14:42 (6 Talkback[s])
(Other stories by Nancy Daniels)
Re-Imagining Linux Platforms to Meet the Needs of Cloud Service Providers
By Nancy Daniels, VNU
Question marks were raised over the future of Hewlett Packard's
(HP) Unix variant last week when it announced it was positioning
Linux as its third strategic platform alongside HP/UX and
Microsoft's Windows 2000.
The move follows the decision by industry heavyweights such as
IBM and Dell to back the open source operating system (OS). IBM
plans to support the offering across its entire hardware family,
for example, while Dell has committed to spend $750 million on
Linux research and development during this year alone.
HP, on the other hand, has said it will now support Caldera,
SuSE, TurboLinux and Debian Linux on its NetServer PC boxes in
addition to Red Hat Linux. Red Hat, Caldera, SuSE and TurboLinux
will also be certified to run on its business desktop PC families,
including Vectras and Brios.
More significantly, however, the vendor plans to port Linux to
its 64bit PA-Risc chip, which forms the basis of its Unix server
line, and is developing a Linux runtime environment that will
enable Linux applications (binary code) to run on its HP/UX Unix
This, it says, will mean that developers no longer need to
recompile their Linux packages if they want to build them on an
HP/UX box before deploying them on a Linux-based one.
But it is unclear where this will leave HP/UX into the future.
HP currently licenses the SVR5 Unix source code, which forms the
basis of HP/UX, from the Santa Cruz Operation (SCO). SCO, however,
is in the process of selling its Unix business to Linux
distributor, Caldera. And the move inevitably raises question marks
over what will happen to both SVR5 and SCO's UnixWare derivative
Caldera has said that it intends to layer Linux services over
the UnixWare kernel and will add Linux application programming
interfaces (API) to the OS. This means that, to all intents and
purposes, UnixWare will appear as Linux to users and
It also means that developers will be able to write applications
that can run on both Linux proper, which will be targeted at the
low end of the market, and the new manifestation of UnixWare, which
will be sold at the high end.
But it is unclear how this move will affect future development
of SVR5, and ultimately the original equipment manufacturers that
Project Trillian enters the equation
To make matters even more complex, HP is also a member of Project
Trillian, which is developing a 64bit version of Linux. This is due
to be released at the same time as Intel's 64bit Itanium chip -
which was, coincidentally, jointly developed with HP - later this
Version 11.20 of HP/UX is also scheduled to run on IA64,
although HP is unlikely to base its servers on 64bit Intel chips
until the release of the second generation McKinley processor in
2001. The latest commercially available release of HP/UX is
At the moment, however, it is unclear whether HP is adding
the Linux runtime environment and API to 64bit HP/UX to enable more
applications to run on it, so prolonging its life, or whether it,
like Caldera, eventually intends to convert the OS into an apparent
high-end Linux variant.
Developing operating systems is not cheap, a fact that is borne
out by the continuing consolidation of the Unix market, which is
also threatened by the creep of Microsoft's Windows 2000 up the
And HP has already been much criticised in the past for
de-emphasising Unix in favour of Windows 2000. Having two Unix
flavours on its hands is only likely to send out even more mixed
messages and confuse its customers further, however, especially as
Linux moves into the high end over time.
No forced move to Linux
But Terry Walden, marketing manager for HP 9000 and HP/UX, said the
company had no intention of dropping HP/UX and forcing customers to
move to Linux. It would create a seamless environment to make
migration as simple as possible for those customers that wanted to
move, however, he explained.
"We're not about telling customers what they should be doing. We
think that different customers have different views. Long term,
there will be 100,000 customers using HP/UX and 100,000 customers
using Linux," he added.
But Gary Barnett, head of research in North America for research
group Ovum, said HP's move indicated that Linux had now gained a
significant foothold in the Unix market.
"We're seeing Unix vendors almost obliged to support Linux
because of the market share opportunities that surround it. It's a
very positive move for Linux. One of the essential things for
operating system success is broadband and preferably heavyweight
support for it," he explained.
Although Barnett admits he was sceptical about Linux's potential
at first, he now predicts that it could be as little as 18 months
before the OS starts to appear at the top of IT department lists,
alongside other Unix variants and Windows 2000. He attributes this
to the mindshare it has already won in the industry.
"When you watch technology for any length of time, you realise
its not always the best technology that wins. It's not just about
technology. It's about marketing and mindshare," he attested.
But although Barnett believes that Linux still has some way to
go before it will be capable of competing at the high end of the
market, he said the OS's endorsement by IBM and HP should provide
users with "a degree of confidence" that could speed up its
Consolidation against competition
He added that the Unix market had little choice but to consolidate
around Linux over time, though, so it could compete more
effectively against the threat of Windows 2000.
"Windows 2000 is a very good operating system. It's a very
serious competitor. If the Unix world allows Microsoft to compete
with Unix variants, it's making Microsoft's task a lot easier. But
Microsoft is acutely aware that Linux as a competitive force is
growing in importance day by day. The gap between Linux the reality
and Linux the hype is narrowing very quickly," he said.
"What end users want is something that works and that is not
going to cost them an arm and a leg to run," he added.
But other industry watchers believe that Linux has a long way to
go before it will take over from Unix. Mat Hanrahan, an analyst at
Bloor Research, attested that HP's adoption of Linux would not
necessarily spell the end for HP/UX. "The old grey-bearded kind of
Unix has considerable shelf-life," he claimed.
The leading Unix variants will continue to lead at the high end
of the market for the time being, he said, with Linux relegated to
the commodity end. "Stripped-down Linux managing appliances - I can
see that happening in the future," he added.
Meta Group analyst Phil Dawson agreed. "Linux needs to mature
before the market even considers replacing one of the three leading
Unix[es]. It needs to move up the food chain and that is a two to
three year process," he said.
- BW: MSC.Software and HP Sign Worldwide Reseller Agreement for Linux Clusters(Aug 22, 2000)
- LinuxPR: Linuxcare Gives Seal of Approval to HP NetServer Systems and Business Desktop PC's(Aug 16, 2000)
- LinuxPR: TurboLinux Selected by Hewlett-Packard for High-End Workstations
(Aug 15, 2000)
- BW: HP Expands Commitment to Linux; New Products and Services Advance Linux...(Aug 15, 2000)
- CNET News.com: HP joins crowd in boosting Linux position(Aug 11, 2000)
- VNU Net: HP to unveil commitment to Linux(Aug 11, 2000)
- ZDNet UK/Reuters: HP to expand commitment to Linux(Aug 11, 2000)
- BW: VA Linux and Hewlett-Packard Host Open Source Printing Summit(Aug 08, 2000)
- NetworkWorld: HP adds Linux mgmt. to its OpenView mix(Jun 20, 2000)
- eWeek: Intel, HP post IA-64 developer's kit for Linux(Jun 13, 2000)
- Smart Partner: HP To Unveil New OS Next Week(Jun 10, 2000)