Subject: URGENT SECURITY ADVISORY FOR SSH SECURE SHELL 3.0.0
Date: Fri, 20 Jul 2001 17:34:02 -0700
From: "Stephanie Thomas" <firstname.lastname@example.org>
Dear Secure Shell Community,
A potential remote root exploit has been discovered
in SSH Secure Shell 3.0.0, for Unix only, concerning
accounts with password fields consisting of two or
fewer characters. Unauthorized users could potentially
log in to these accounts using any password, including
an empty password. This affects SSH Secure Shell 3.0.0
for Unix only. This is a problem with password
authentication to the sshd2 daemon. The SSH Secure
Shell client binaries (located by default in
/usr/local/bin) are not affected.
SSH Secure Shell 3.0.1 fixes this problem.
Please note that if using a form of authentication
other than password, AND password authentication
is disabled, you are NOT VULNERABLE to this issue.
Red Hat Linux 6.1 thru 7.1
Solaris 2.6 thru 2.8
Caldera Linux 2.4
Suse Linux 6.4 thru 7.0
Please note that other platforms not listed here
may also be vulnerable.
PLATFORMS NOT IMPACTED:
Tru64 4.0.G, NetBSD, and OpenBSD are not vulnerable.
Please note that other platforms not listed here
may also be immune.
Some stock machines which have default locked accounts
running SSH Secure Shell 3.0 are vulnerable to
arbitrary logins. This is a serious problem with
Solaris, for example, which uses the sequence "NP" to
indicate locked administrative accounts such as "lp",
"adm", "bin" etc. Some Linux machines which have
accounts with !! in the etc/passwd or /etc/shadow such
as xfs or gdm are also vulnerable. Since it is relatively
easy to become root after gaining access to certain
accounts, we consider this a potential root exploit.
During password authentication, if the field containing
the encrypted password in /etc/shadow, /etc/password,
etc. is two or less characters long, SSH 3.0.0 will
allow anyone to access that account with ANY password.
The bug is in the code that compares the result of calling
crypt(pw, salt) with the value of the encrypted password
in the /etc/shadow (or /etc/password) file. SSH Secure Shell
Server 3.0.0 does a bounded string compare bounded to the
length of the value stored in aforementioned file (2
characters in this case) against the return value of
crypt(). The return value of crypt() is 13 characters,
with the first two characters being the salt value itself.
The salt value used is the first two characters of the
encrypted password in /etc/shadow (or /etc/password). A
2 character string comparison between the 2 character
encrypted password in /etc/shadow, and the 13 character
crypt() return value, whose first two characters ARE the
2 characters from the password in /etc/shadow. The strings
match, and the 3.0.0 daemon then accepts the password, no
matter what is input.
Immediately upgrade to SSH Secure Shell 3.0.1
which will be available on our e-commerce site
http://commerce.ssh.com shortly, and is available
on the ftp site now - ftp://ftp.ssh.com/pub/ssh
A patch for 3.0.0 source code is also available there.
Disable password authentication to the SSH Secure Shell
daemon (sshd2) in the /etc/ssh2/sshd2_config and use
another form of authentication such as public key,
SecurID, Kerberos, certificates, Smart Cards, or
hostbased to authenticate your users. These alternative
authentication methods are NOT VULNERABLE. Please see
our SSH Secure Shell support web pages for more
information on how to enable these authentication methods.
If you cannot disable password authentication fully,
limit access to the sshd2 daemon to allow only users
with entries in the /etc/passwd and /etc/shadow which
exceed two characters. This can be done using the
AllowUsers, AllowGroups, DenyUsers, and DenyGroups
keywords in the /etc/ssh2/sshd2_config file. See
our SSH Secure Shell support web pages
http://www.ssh.com/support/ssh and man sshd2_config
for more information.
Assign a valid password for each account. Because
it is possible that assigning a password to some
system accounts could cause problems on some operating
systems, this work-around is limited and is provided
only as a last-resort alternative.
Use the following patch in the source code:
Location near line 953, before
/*Authentication is accepted if the encrypted
passwords are identical. */
if (strlen(correct_passwd) < 13)
We apologize for any inconvenience this may cause.
SSH Communications Security takes security issues very
seriously, and a CERT advisory and submission to Bugtraq
regarding this issue have been submitted. Please make
every effort to ensure that your systems are protected
using one of the above methods as quickly as possible.
As this information becomes widely known, your systems could
be at even greater risk if appropriate measures are not taken.
SSH is fully committed to serving and supporting our users
and products. While we may not be able to address each request
for information on this issue individually, we will
make publicly available any relevant information possible
which addresses your questions and concerns.
This vulnerability was found and reported by an
anonymous system administrator at the Helsinki University
of Technology and by Andrew Newman of Yale University.