Linux Today: Linux News On Internet Time.
Search Linux Today
search.internet.com
Linux News Sections:  Blog -  Developer -  High Performance -  Infrastructure -  IT Management -  Security -  Storage -
Linux Today Navigation
LT Home
Preferences
Contribute
Link to Us
Search
Linux Jobs

Become a Marketplace Partner

internet.commerce
Be a Commerce Partner














The Linux Channel at internet.com
Linux Today
Enterprise Linux Today
Apache Today
JustLinux.com
Linux Planet
PHPBuilder
All Linux Devices
Technology Jobs

JustTechJobs.com

LinuxToday Newsletters
Subscribe News
Subscribe PR
Subscribe Security

internet.com
IT
Developer
Internet News
Small Business
Personal Technology

Search internet.com
Advertise
Corporate Info
Newsletters
Tech Jobs
E-mail Offers

 







Current Newswire:

Intel Linux Graphics Shine With Fedora 12

Editor's Note: Do It Yourself "Cloud"

Google Chrome OS: First looks, first impressions

Kernel Log: Coming in 2.6.32 (Part 3) - Storage

TV Mythos Renewed: MythTV 0.22 with Many Improvements

Enhancing openSUSE 11.2: Adding Repositories and Packages

A Northwest Nobel option? (Linus for the Nobel Peace prize)

SECURITY: Cloud Computing Security Benefits, Risks and Recommendations

Keeping score in test-driven development with Python, PyLint, unittest, doctest,

Win a CodeWeavers Linux Gaming Rig




Sr Systems Engineer - Solaris - AIX (TX)
Next Step Systems
US-TX-Houston

Justtechjobs.com Post A Job | Post A Resume
:Librenix: The BSD License & the GPL: Why we need both
Librenix: The BSD License & the GPL: Why we need both
Jun 12, 2000, 17 :28 UTC (17 Talkback[s]) (4170 reads)

(Other stories by Morris McGee)

[ Thanks to Ray Yeargin for this link. ]

"Into the ongoing debate, 'The GPL versus the BSD license', I'd like add yet another opinion. I agree with the positive points claimed by both sides, but I don't generally agree with the negative ones directed at the opposition. That is, I think that both licenses have strong points that the other lacks, and further, that the two actually complement each other when both are applied to products in the same market. We need them both."

"The license to choose, of course, depends on your goals. The BSDL is less restrictive and is, therefore, more free. The GPL, while less free, guarantees that published derivitive works retain the original set of freedoms (and restrictions). Therefore, if you want maximum freedom for the licensee, the BSDL is best. If you want guaranteed access to the source of future published code, the GPL is best. In practice, each allows the creation of open source code that the other would not. If I had to assign the common labels to them, I'd say that the BSDL is more consistent with the term 'free software' and that the GPL is more aggressively 'open source'."

Complete Story

Related Stories:
ZDNet: Fatal flaw in BSD? - The Kerberos Affair shows weakness of BSD software license.(Jun 06, 2000)
Linux.com: Piracy, Marketing, and the GPL(Mar 17, 2000)
32 Bits Online: GPL and BSD: explication and comparison(Jun 19, 1999)
osOpinion: Why BSD is more free than GPL is(Dec 29, 1999)
Linuxcare: Fear of Forking, How the GPL Keeps Linux Unified and Strong(Nov 18, 1999)


Index Mode   |   Flat Mode   |   Thread Mode   |   Thread Flat  
  Talkback(s) Name  and Date
"The license to choose, of course, depen ...   Does not make sense. :O)   
Derek Neighbors
Jun 12, 2000, 18:07:06
 
Your explanation,

"The mistake is you ...   Re: Does not make sense. :O) Excellent Description   
Bruce
Jun 12, 2000, 18:41:13
 
I'll start by saying that any "open  ...   GPL for me...   
Rick F
Jun 12, 2000, 19:07:01
 
It is truly wonderful to have a selectio ...   Actually, one can argue precisely the opposite...D   
Dean Pannell (a.k.a. dinotrac)
Jun 12, 2000, 19:24:33
 
the author whose freedom the BSD license ...   Agree but just an observation:   
Alastor
Jun 12, 2000, 19:47:07
 
"I think most struggle because they have ...   I know what 'free' is...   
David Johnson
Jun 12, 2000, 20:22:45
 
Kinda hard to be a thief when you're ...   Re: Agree but just an observation:   
Dean Pannell (a.k.a. dinotrac)
Jun 12, 2000, 20:23:56
 
You're right from the point of view  ...   Re: Dean Pannell   
Alastor
Jun 12, 2000, 22:14:31
 
Sorry, i think these philosophical divag ...   Stupidity   
tiredofthis
Jun 12, 2000, 22:32:42
 
Sigh... Time to break out the dictionary ...   Theft   
David Johnson
Jun 12, 2000, 23:05:24
 
The original author, non-contributing us ...   GPL: No guarantee downstream versions published   
Andrew Johnson
Jun 12, 2000, 23:37:28
 
The idea that the BSD license is "bad" b ...   my two cents   
Ted Clark
Jun 13, 2000, 03:06:56
 
> p.s. If RMS decries the term "piracy"  ...   Re: Theft   
Rainer Weikusat
Jun 13, 2000, 10:24:16
 
BSD gives you all freedoms including mak ...   Bsd and slavery   
Jean François Martinez
Jun 13, 2000, 13:34:07
 
A few points about freedom, property rig ...   Minor lecture on property rights v. political righ   
Jason Fletcher
Jun 13, 2000, 15:48:54
 
Both, in an implicit and explicit way, I ...   Re: Jason Fletcher   
Alastor
Jun 13, 2000, 17:23:11
 
You say that it is incorrect and irrespo ...   Re: Re: Jason Fletcher   
Jason Fletcher
Jun 13, 2000, 19:04:42
 
  Home | Search Talkbacks | Customize View    Top of Page  



Enter your comments below:

* Your Name:

* Your Email Address:

* Subject:

CC: [will also send this talkback to an E-Mail address]

* Comments:

Tags allowed:<I>,<B> and <U>. See our talkback-policy for more about talkback content.

Fields marked with * are required!






..............................




All times are recorded in UTC.
Linux is a trademark of Linus Torvalds.
Powered by Linux, Apache and PHP

internet.commediabistro.comJusttechjobs.comGraphics.com

Search:

WebMediaBrands Corporate Info

Legal Notices, Licensing, Permissions, Privacy Policy.
Advertise | Newsletters | Shopping | E-mail Offers | Freelance Jobs