Linux Today: Linux News On Internet Time.
Search Linux Today
search.internet.com
Linux News Sections:  Blog -  Developer -  High Performance -  Infrastructure -  IT Management -  Security -  Storage -
Linux Today Navigation
LT Home
Preferences
Contribute
Link to Us
Search
Linux Jobs

Become a Marketplace Partner

internet.commerce
Be a Commerce Partner














The Linux Channel at internet.com
Linux Today
Enterprise Linux Today
Apache Today
JustLinux.com
Linux Planet
PHPBuilder
All Linux Devices
Technology Jobs

JustTechJobs.com

LinuxToday Newsletters
Subscribe News
Subscribe PR
Subscribe Security

internet.com
IT
Developer
Internet News
Small Business
Personal Technology

Search internet.com
Advertise
Corporate Info
Newsletters
Tech Jobs
E-mail Offers

 







Current Newswire:

Intel Linux Graphics Shine With Fedora 12

Editor's Note: Do It Yourself "Cloud"

Google Chrome OS: First looks, first impressions

Kernel Log: Coming in 2.6.32 (Part 3) - Storage

TV Mythos Renewed: MythTV 0.22 with Many Improvements

Enhancing openSUSE 11.2: Adding Repositories and Packages

A Northwest Nobel option? (Linus for the Nobel Peace prize)

SECURITY: Cloud Computing Security Benefits, Risks and Recommendations

Keeping score in test-driven development with Python, PyLint, unittest, doctest,

Win a CodeWeavers Linux Gaming Rig




Sr Systems Engineer - Solaris - AIX (TX)
Next Step Systems
US-TX-Houston

Justtechjobs.com Post A Job | Post A Resume
:CMPnet.asia: Analyst Finds SCO's "Proof" Credible
CMPnet.asia: Analyst Finds SCO's "Proof" Credible
Jun 6, 2003, 14 :30 UTC (70 Talkback[s]) (13169 reads)

(Other stories by John Foley)

"One of the first observers to see the evidence in the SCO Group Inc.'s intellectual-property claim against IBM and the Linux community says there are direct similarities between the Unix code that SCO claims control over and the Linux operating system.

"'My impression is that [SCO's claim] is credible,' says Laura DiDio, a Yankee Group analyst who was shown the evidence by SCO Group earlier this week. 'It appears to be the same' code. But DiDio says the developing battle could hinge on legal fine points that are hard to sort out in the current atmosphere of claims, denials, and counterclaims.

"Apparently the most telling evidence is that parts of the SCO code and Linux code include identical annotations made by developers when they wrote the programs, says DiDio, who compares such notes to the signature or fingerprint of a developer's work. 'The fact that these appear to be transposed from Unix System V into Linux I find to be very damaging.' DiDio says she was shown several instances where the source code and developer's comments in one operating system were the same as in the other operating system..."

Complete Story

Related Stories:
MozillaQuest.com: Is SCO NDA Sideshow Setting a Trap for Analysts and Linux Developers?(Jun 06, 2003)
Update: CBS.MarketWatch: Novell Challenges SCO's Unix Claims(May 29, 2003)
Linux Journal: SCO to Reveal Allegedly Copied Code(May 15, 2003)


Index Mode   |   Flat Mode   |   Thread Mode   |   Thread Flat  
  Talkback(s) Name  and Date
...And here comes the setup.... I wonder ...   Setup   
da
Jun 6, 2003, 14:45:47
 
I have only one question. How can SCO su ...   just one question ..   
nilesh
Jun 6, 2003, 14:49:37
 
The World Book Encyclopedia contains the ...   Exact copies, eh?   
ac
Jun 6, 2003, 14:50:15
 
similarity does not prove that it's  ...   Just another PR firm of $CO   
Noel
Jun 6, 2003, 14:50:28
 
"One of the first observers to see the e ...   Unix Code Similarities   
horne
Jun 6, 2003, 14:50:55
 
The fact that there is code in common do ...   Origin of code in question   
Troy Roberts
Jun 6, 2003, 14:53:19
 
This sounds like the code in both Bell/A ...   both standing on the shoulders of the same giants   
Arthur Marsh
Jun 6, 2003, 14:54:43
 
Is it a good time to buy some sco stocks ...   time to buy some sco stocks?   
John Walters
Jun 6, 2003, 15:03:27
 
Did she get SCO's "version" of eithe ...   Chain of Custody? Which "developer"?   
TJ Miller jr
Jun 6, 2003, 15:03:49
 
to do this comparison.She has no clue ab ...   Laura Didio NOT qualified   
Noel
Jun 6, 2003, 15:03:59
 
Didn't see any comment regarding whe ...   Who Copied from Who?   
david
Jun 6, 2003, 15:07:27
 
How similar is it to the free BSD codeor ...   The question is   
Uno Engborg
Jun 6, 2003, 15:08:50
 
Something smells very fishy here.If ther ...   No Funny Business   
Nicholas Donovan
Jun 6, 2003, 15:09:27
 
Certainly, the opinion of any single dev ...   IF this is true....   
Glen
Jun 6, 2003, 15:10:56
 
What is the reason for someone copying c ...   SCO code and Linux code include identical annotati   
Silviu
Jun 6, 2003, 15:17:43
 
Do this same comments appear in BSD?  Wh ...   so   
Bill Nuxli
Jun 6, 2003, 15:18:08
 
First salvo.. "Google is my Friend"And s ...   Laurai DiDio Who??   
Pascal Abessolo
Jun 6, 2003, 15:19:04
 
Suppose this was true, then it shouldn&# ...   If True then.   
g
Jun 6, 2003, 15:26:34
 
> And the world turns......  Who's g ...   Re: IF this is true....   
is
Jun 6, 2003, 15:26:54
 
So the scam continues and SCO finds some ...   full of holes   
jeffrey l koehn
Jun 6, 2003, 15:27:12
 
> What point am I trying to make?  Just  ...   Re: Unix Code Similarities - Merger Doctrine   
Julio Sánchez
Jun 6, 2003, 15:30:21
 
Boy, this story gets wierder and wierder ...   curiouser and curiouser   
senkwe
Jun 6, 2003, 15:32:37
 
> to do this comparison.> She has no clu ...   Re: Laura Didio NOT qualified   
is
Jun 6, 2003, 15:35:31
 
The entire linux source code history is  ...   simple plan   
einstein
Jun 6, 2003, 15:43:31
 
 So the scam continues and SCO finds som ...   Re: full of holes   
Charles Hixson
Jun 6, 2003, 15:48:38
 
Let us all see the code and back track i ...   Let me see the code   
Greg&Stevens
Jun 6, 2003, 15:52:42
 
Lets not get too upset about this. At le ...   Lets not get too upset   
Daniel
Jun 6, 2003, 16:05:10
 
given x and y, write an C code to switch ...   Example of simililarity   
MeLikeToPost
Jun 6, 2003, 16:05:26
 
> What is the reason for someone copying ...   Re: SCO code and Linux code include identical anno   
MeLikeToPost
Jun 6, 2003, 16:07:57
 
see www.inquirer.netSCO releases draconi ...   Laura Ditto   
harv
Jun 6, 2003, 16:08:21
 
> What is the reason for someone copying ...   Re: SCO code and Linux code include identical anno   
S. Chauveau
Jun 6, 2003, 16:14:12
 
If history has shown anything, the so-ca ...   Complete Rubbish   
g
Jun 6, 2003, 16:15:38
 
When is SCO going to provide details of  ...   Will SCO ever have to release code publicly?   
Anon
Jun 6, 2003, 16:20:09
 
Oh, they have code similar to ours so th ...   SCO had better be danmed careful here   
Joe User
Jun 6, 2003, 16:21:53
 
I write code for a big corporation. Whil ...   Annotations   
Sauiron
Jun 6, 2003, 16:25:01
 
I'm not IP law expert, just a linux  ...   smells fishy   
satomato
Jun 6, 2003, 16:25:53
 
Even if the code in Linux is copied dire ...   means nothing   
Alan
Jun 6, 2003, 16:35:25
 
It's easy to prove with a high degre ...   Questions   
David Wollmann
Jun 6, 2003, 16:36:21
 
>given x and y, write an C code to switc ...   Re: Example of similarity   
Joe User
Jun 6, 2003, 16:37:18
 
Even though the SCO suit is about trade  ...   Remove the offending comments!!!   
Dean Pannell (a.k.a. dinotrac)
Jun 6, 2003, 16:37:22
 
The purpose of the NDA is to allow peopl ...   You're forgetting the NDA   
Charles Hixson
Jun 6, 2003, 16:37:34
 
I second that ...From Giga Web site" Ple ...   Re: Laura Didio NOT qualified   
ANON
Jun 6, 2003, 16:49:28
 
and this is IBM being awfully quiet abou ...   One thing bothers me   
is
Jun 6, 2003, 16:55:41
 
> > What is the reason for someone copyi ...   Re: Re: SCO code and Linux code include identical   
Silviu
Jun 6, 2003, 17:05:30
 
this is probably stuff that was lifted f ...   Exactly!   
kws
Jun 6, 2003, 17:16:52
 
> What is the reason for someone copying ...   Re: SCO code and Linux code include identical anno   
SM
Jun 6, 2003, 18:54:32
 
I ask this with question marks as I' ...   GiGa Just Locked Themselves Out.??? (Q   
Nicholas Donovan
Jun 6, 2003, 19:04:56
 
I am not so sure comments copied from ot ...   Re: Remove the offending comments!!!   
SM
Jun 6, 2003, 19:08:03
 
> If they think there is nothing stolen  ...   Re: One thing bothers me   
SM
Jun 6, 2003, 19:25:50
 
If I was walking through the tropical ra ...   my opinion of analysts   
junglejim
Jun 6, 2003, 19:34:38
 
> > What is the reason for someone copyi ...   Re: Re: SCO code and Linux code include identical   
Richard Westerveld
Jun 6, 2003, 19:53:56
 
> and this is IBM being awfully quiet ab ...   Re: One thing bothers me (Don't Let it)   
Nicholas Donovan
Jun 6, 2003, 19:55:14
 
 So, you're trying to say that someo ...   Re: Re: Re: SCO code and Linux code include identi   
GrayGeek
Jun 6, 2003, 20:00:46
 
I thought I remembered something like th ...   Re: Re: Re: Re: SCO code and Linux code include id   
jeffrey l koehn
Jun 6, 2003, 21:02:17
 
I wonder if Laura knows that the same ch ...   What would Laura say?.........   
Harlan
Jun 6, 2003, 21:04:43
 
Trade secrete law says that a Trade Secr ...   trade Secretes   
Tim Dion
Jun 6, 2003, 21:21:32
 
Yeah and up till Wednesday I worked for  ...   Re: Re: One thing bothers me (Don't Let it)   
Nic
Jun 6, 2003, 21:35:22
 
We work in an industry where a company o ...   Remember   
John Bell
Jun 6, 2003, 22:26:07
 
> and this is IBM being awfully quiet ab ...   Re: One thing bothers me   
Scott Carr
Jun 6, 2003, 22:29:52
 
> Wouldn't a GiGa analyst having sig ...   Re: GiGa Just Locked Themselves Out.???   
Scott Carr
Jun 6, 2003, 22:35:42
 
From significant experience that I have  ...   Proof   
Mario Miyojim
Jun 6, 2003, 23:36:02
 
SCO shows here code snippets. It should  ...   Why didn't she say WHEN that code was added   
Brandioch Conner
Jun 7, 2003, 01:24:21
 
here is the link to Laura's bio:http ...   Re: Laura Didio NOT qualified   
googlebot
Jun 7, 2003, 04:54:44
 
Now, we can be quite sure that SCO has s ...   Double-edged evidence   
Rafael J.
Jun 7, 2003, 11:22:34
 
> If the court subsequently decides SCO  ...   Re: Will SCO ever have to release code publicly   
SM
Jun 7, 2003, 12:52:48
 
If there are identical annotations, comm ...   SCO Unix is the big risk - not Linux   
SM
Jun 7, 2003, 13:09:40
 
> to do this comparison.> She has no clu ...   Re: Laura Didio NOT qualified   
ClosedSourceGuy
Jun 8, 2003, 02:31:31
 
> If Laura Didio is not qualified to mak ...   Re: Re: Laura Didio NOT qualified   
SM
Jun 8, 2003, 18:15:25
 
> given x and y, write an C code to swit ...   Re: Example of simililarity   
Trevor Spiteri
Jun 9, 2003, 06:56:26
 
Anyway, formal education in CS (theory)  ...   Re: Re: Laura Didio NOT qualified   
C. Whitman
Jun 10, 2003, 06:38:37
 
  Home | Search Talkbacks | Customize View    Top of Page  



Enter your comments below:

* Your Name:

* Your Email Address:

* Subject:

CC: [will also send this talkback to an E-Mail address]

* Comments:

Tags allowed:<I>,<B> and <U>. See our talkback-policy for more about talkback content.

Fields marked with * are required!






..............................




All times are recorded in UTC.
Linux is a trademark of Linus Torvalds.
Powered by Linux, Apache and PHP

internet.commediabistro.comJusttechjobs.comGraphics.com

Search:

WebMediaBrands Corporate Info

Legal Notices, Licensing, Permissions, Privacy Policy.
Advertise | Newsletters | Shopping | E-mail Offers | Freelance Jobs